It makes sense for networks which support arbitrary data to do as part of their
address. This reduces the ability to perform DoSs, achieves better performance,
and better uses the type system (as now networks we don't support data on don't
have a data field).
Updates the Ethereum address definition in serai-client accordingly
* Remove subxt
Removes ~20 crates from our Cargo.lock.
Removes downloading the metadata and enables removing the getMetadata RPC route
(relevant to #379).
Moves forward #337.
Done now due to distinctions in the subxt 0.32 API surface which make it
justifiable to not update.
* fmt, update due to deny triggering on a yanked crate
* Correct the handling of substrate_block_notifier now that it's ephemeral, not long-lived
* Correct URL in tests/coordinator from ws to http
* Add SignalsConfig to chain_spec
* Correct multiexp feature flagging for rand_core std
* Remove bincode for borsh
Replaces a non-canonical encoding with a canonical encoding which additionally
should be faster.
Also fixes an issue where we used bincode in transcripts where it cannot be
trusted.
This ended up fixing a myriad of other bugs observed, unfortunately.
Accordingly, it either has to be merged or the bug fixes from it must be ported
to a new PR.
* Make serde optional, minimize usage
* Make borsh an optional dependency of substrate/ crates
* Remove unused dependencies
* Use [u8; 64] where possible in the processor messages
* Correct borsh feature flagging
Relevant to #394.
Prevents hand-over due to hand-over occurring via a `Batch` publication.
Expects a new protocol to restore functionality (after a retirement of the
current protocol).
* Move pallet-asset-conversion
* update licensing
* initial integration
* Integrate Currency & Assets types
* integrate liquidity tokens
* fmt
* integrate dex pallet tests
* fmt
* compilation error fixes
* integrate dex benchmarks
* fmt
* cargo clippy
* replace all occurrences of "asset" with "coin"
* add the actual add liq/swap logic to in-instructions
* add client side & tests
* fix deny
* Lint and changes
- Renames InInstruction::AddLiquidity to InInstruction::SwapAndAddLiquidity
- Makes create_pool an internal function
- Makes dex-pallet exclusively create pools against a native coin
- Removes various fees
- Adds new crates to GH workflow
* Fix rebase artifacts
* Correct other rebase artifact
* Correct CI specification for liquidity-tokens
* Correct primitives' test to the standardized pallet account scheme
---------
Co-authored-by: Luke Parker <lukeparker5132@gmail.com>
Resolves#353
Implements code such that:
- 80% of validators (by stake) must be in favor of a signal for the network to
be
- 80% of networks (by stake) must be in favor of a signal for it to be locked
in
- After a signal has been locked in for two weeks, the network halts
The intention is to:
1) Not allow validators to unilaterally declare new consensus rules.
No method of declaring new consensus rules is provided by this pallet. Solely a
way to deprecate the current rules, with a signaled for successor. All nodes
must then individually decide whether or not to download and run a new node
which has new rules, and if so, which rules.
2) Not place blobs on chain.
Even if they'd be reproducible, it's just a lot of data to chuck on the
blockchain.
* initial implementation
* add function to get a balance of an account
* add support for multiple coins
* rename pallet to "coins-pallet"
* replace balances, assets and tokens pallet with coins pallet in runtime
* add total supply info
* update client side for new Coins pallet
* handle fees
* bug fixes
* Update FeeAccount test
* Fmt
* fix pr comments
* remove extraneous Imbalance type
* Minor tweaks
---------
Co-authored-by: Luke Parker <lukeparker5132@gmail.com>
Adds Event::SetRetired to validator-sets.
Emit TributaryRetired.
Replaces is_active_set, which made multiple network requests, with
is_retired_tributary, a DB read.
Performs most of the removals necessary upon TributaryRetired.
Still needs to clean up the actual Tributary/Tendermint tasks.
* Revert "Correct the prior documented TOCTOU"
This reverts commit d50fe87801.
* Correct the prior documented TOCTOU
d50fe87801 edited the challenge for the Batch to
fix it. This won't produce Batch n+1 until Batch n is successfully published
and verified. It's an alternative strategy able to be reviewed, with a much
smaller impact to scope.
Now, if a malicious validator set publishes a malicious `Batch` at the last
moment, it'll cause all future `Batch`s signed by the next validator set to
require a bool being set (yet they never will set it).
This will prevent the handover.
The only overhead is having two distinct `batch_message` calls on-chain.
pre_dispatch is guaranteed by documentation to be called and persisted.
validate_unsigned is not, though the provided pre_dispatch does by default call
validate_unsigned. By explicitly providing our own pre_dispatch, we accomplish
the bounds we require and expect, only being invalidated on Substrate
redefining their API.
We should still test this, yet since we call retire_session in
validate_unsigned, any test of rotation will test it's being properly called.
Renames Update to SignedBatch.
Checks Batch equality via a hash of the InInstructions. That prevents needing
to keep the Batch in node state or TX introspect.
* restrict batch size to ~25kb
* add batch size check to node
* rate limit batches to 1 per serai block
* add support for multiple batches for block
* fix review comments
* Misc fixes
Doesn't yet update tests/processor until data flow is inspected.
* Move the block from SignId to ProcessorMessage::BatchPreprocesses
* Misc clean up
---------
Co-authored-by: Luke Parker <lukeparker5132@gmail.com>
Provides a DST, and associated metadata as beneficial.
Also utilizes MuSig's context to session-bind. Since set_keys_messages also
binds to set, this is semi-redundant, yet that's appreciated.
Updates to polkadot-v0.9.40, with a variety of dependency updates accordingly.
Substrate thankfully now uses k256 0.13, pathing the way for #256. We couldn't
upgrade to polkadot-v0.9.40 without this due to polkadot-v0.9.40 having
fundamental changes to syncing. While we could've updated tendermint, it's not
worth the continued development effort given its inability to work with
multiple validator sets.
Purges sc-tendermint. Keeps tendermint-machine for #163.
Closes#137, #148, #157, #171. #96 and #99 should be re-scoped/clarified. #134
and #159 also should be clarified. #169 is also no longer a priority since
we're only considering temporal deployments of tendermint. #170 also isn't
since we're looking at effectively sharded validator sets, so there should
be no singular large set needing high performance.
The original intent was to use inherent transactions to prevent needing to vote
on-chain, which would spam the chain with worthless votes. Inherent
transactions, and our Tendermint library, would use the BFT's processs voting
to also vote on all included transactions. This perfectly collapses integrity
voting creating *no additional on-chain costs*.
Unfortunately, this led to issues such as #6, along with questions of validator
scalability when all validators are expencted to participate in consensus (in
order to vote on if the included instructions are valid). This has been
summarized in #241.
With this change, we can remove Tendermint from Substrate. This greatly
decreases our complexity. While I'm unhappy with the amount of time spent on
it, just to reach this conclusion, thankfully tendermint-machine itself is
still usable for #163. This also has reached a tipping point recently as the
polkadot-v0.9.40 branch of substrate changed how syncing works, requiring
further changes to sc-tendermint. These have no value if we're just going to
get rid of it later, due to fundamental design issues, yet I would like to
keep Substrate updated.
This should be followed by moving back to GRANDPA, enabling closing most open
Tendermint issues.
Please note the current in-instructions-pallet does not actually verify the
included signature yet. It's marked TODO, despite this bing critical.
* Initial work on a message box
* Finish message-box (untested)
* Expand documentation
* Embed the recipient in the signature challenge
Prevents a message from A -> B from being read as from A -> C.
* Update documentation by bifurcating sender/receiver
* Panic on receiving an invalid signature
If we've received an invalid signature in an authenticated system, a
service is malicious, critically faulty (equivalent to malicious), or
the message layer has been compromised (or is otherwise critically
faulty).
Please note a receiver who handles a message they shouldn't will trigger
this. That falls under being critically faulty.
* Documentation and helper methods
SecureMessage::new and SecureMessage::serialize.
Secure Debug for MessageBox.
* Have SecureMessage not be serialized by default
Allows passing around in-memory, if desired, and moves the error from
decrypt to new (which performs deserialization).
Decrypt no longer has an error since it panics if given an invalid
signature, due to this being intranet code.
* Explain and improve nonce handling
Includes a missing zeroize call.
* Rebase to latest develop
Updates to transcript 0.2.0.
* Add a test for the MessageBox
* Export PrivateKey and PublicKey
* Also test serialization
* Add a key_gen binary to message_box
* Have SecureMessage support Serde
* Add encrypt_to_bytes and decrypt_from_bytes
* Support String ser via base64
* Rename encrypt/decrypt to encrypt_bytes/decrypt_to_bytes
* Directly operate with values supporting Borsh
* Use bincode instead of Borsh
By staying inside of serde, we'll support many more structs. While
bincode isn't canonical, we don't need canonicity on an authenticated,
internal system.
* Turn PrivateKey, PublicKey into structs
Uses Zeroizing for the PrivateKey per #150.
* from_string functions intended for loading from an env
* Use &str for PublicKey from_string (now from_str)
The PrivateKey takes the String to take ownership of its memory and
zeroize it. That isn't needed with PublicKeys.
* Finish updating from develop
* Resolve warning
* Use ZeroizingAlloc on the key_gen binary
* Move message-box from crypto/ to common/
* Move key serialization functions to ser
* add/remove functions in MessageBox
* Implement Hash on dalek_ff_group Points
* Make MessageBox generic to its key
Exposes a &'static str variant for internal use and a RistrettoPoint
variant for external use.
* Add Private to_string as deprecated
Stub before more competent tooling is deployed.
* Private to_public
* Test both Internal and External MessageBox, only use PublicKey in the pub API
* Remove panics on invalid signatures
Leftover from when this was solely internal which is now unsafe.
* Chicken scratch a Scanner task
* Add a write function to the DKG library
Enables writing directly to a file.
Also modifies serialize to return Zeroizing<Vec<u8>> instead of just Vec<u8>.
* Make dkg::encryption pub
* Remove encryption from MessageBox
* Use a 64-bit block number in Substrate
We use a 64-bit block number in general since u32 only works for 120 years
(with a 1 second block time). As some chains even push the 1 second threshold,
especially ones based on DAG consensus, this becomes potentially as low as 60
years.
While that should still be plenty, it's not worth wondering/debating. Since
Serai uses 64-bit block numbers elsewhere, this ensures consistency.
* Misc crypto lints
* Get the scanner scratch to compile
* Initial scanner test
* First few lines of scheduler
* Further work on scheduler, solidify API
* Define Scheduler TX format
* Branch creation algorithm
* Document when the branch algorithm isn't perfect
* Only scanned confirmed blocks
* Document Coin
* Remove Canonical/ChainNumber from processor
The processor should be abstracted from canonical numbers thanks to the
coordinator, making this unnecessary.
* Add README documenting processor flow
* Use Zeroize on substrate primitives
* Define messages from/to the processor
* Correct over-specified versioning
* Correct build re: in_instructions::primitives
* Debug/some serde in crypto/
* Use a struct for ValidatorSetInstance
* Add a processor key_gen task
Redos DB handling code.
* Replace trait + impl with wrapper struct
* Add a key confirmation flow to the key gen task
* Document concerns on key_gen
* Start on a signer task
* Add Send to FROST traits
* Move processor lib.rs to main.rs
Adds a dummy main to reduce clippy dead_code warnings.
* Further flesh out main.rs
* Move the DB trait to AsRef<[u8]>
* Signer task
* Remove a panic in bitcoin when there's insufficient funds
Unchecked underflow.
* Have Monero's mine_block mine one block, not 10
It was initially a nicety to deal with the 10 block lock. C::CONFIRMATIONS
should be used for that instead.
* Test signer
* Replace channel expects with log statements
The expects weren't problematic and had nicer code. They just clutter test
output.
* Remove the old wallet file
It predates the coordinator design and shouldn't be used.
* Rename tests/scan.rs to tests/scanner.rs
* Add a wallet test
Complements the recently removed wallet file by adding a test for the scanner,
scheduler, and signer together.
* Work on a run function
Triggers a clippy ICE.
* Resolve clippy ICE
The issue was the non-fully specified lambda in signer.
* Add KeyGenEvent and KeyGenOrder
Needed so we get KeyConfirmed messages from the key gen task.
While we could've read the CoordinatorMessage to see that, routing through the
key gen tasks ensures we only handle it once it's been successfully saved to
disk.
* Expand scanner test
* Clarify processor documentation
* Have the Scanner load keys on boot/save outputs to disk
* Use Vec<u8> for Block ID
Much more flexible.
* Panic if we see the same output multiple times
* Have the Scanner DB mark itself as corrupt when doing a multi-put
This REALLY should be a TX. Since we don't have a TX API right now, this at
least offers detection.
* Have DST'd DB keys accept AsRef<[u8]>
* Restore polling all signers
Writes a custom future to do so.
Also loads signers on boot using what the scanner claims are active keys.
* Schedule OutInstructions
Adds a data field to Payment.
Also cleans some dead code.
* Panic if we create an invalid transaction
Saves the TX once it's successfully signed so if we do panic, we have a copy.
* Route coordinator messages to their respective signer
Requires adding key to the SignId.
* Send SignTransaction orders for all plans
* Add a timer to retry sign_plans when prepare_send fails
* Minor fmt'ing
* Basic Fee API
* Move the change key into Plan
* Properly route activation_number
* Remove ScannerEvent::Block
It's not used under current designs
* Nicen logs
* Add utilities to get a block's number
* Have main issue AckBlock
Also has a few misc lints.
* Parse instructions out of outputs
* Tweak TODOs and remove an unwrap
* Update Bitcoin max input/output quantity
* Only read one piece of data from Monero
Due to output randomization, it's infeasible.
* Embed plan IDs into the TXs they create
We need to stop attempting signing if we've already signed a protocol. Ideally,
any one of the participating signers should be able to provide a proof the TX
was successfully signed. We can't just run a second signing protocol though as
a single malicious signer could complete the TX signature, and publish it,
yet not complete the secondary signature.
The TX itself has to be sufficient to show that the TX matches the plan. This
is done by embedding the ID, so matching addresses/amounts plans are
distinguished, and by allowing verification a TX actually matches a set of
addresses/amounts.
For Monero, this will need augmenting with the ephemeral keys (or usage of a
static seed for them).
* Don't use OP_RETURN to encode the plan ID on Bitcoin
We can use the inputs to distinguih identical-output plans without issue.
* Update OP_RETURN data access
It's not required to be the last output.
* Add Eventualities to Monero
An Eventuality is an effective equivalent to a SignableTransaction. That is
declared not by the inputs it spends, yet the outputs it creates.
Eventualities are also bound to a 32-byte RNG seed, enabling usage of a
hash-based identifier in a SignableTransaction, allowing multiple
SignableTransactions with the same output set to have different Eventualities.
In order to prevent triggering the burning bug, the RNG seed is hashed with
the planned-to-be-used inputs' output keys. While this does bind to them, it's
only loosely bound. The TX actually created may use different inputs entirely
if a forgery is crafted (which requires no brute forcing).
Binding to the key images would provide a strong binding, yet would require
knowing the key images, which requires active communication with the spend
key.
The purpose of this is so a multisig can identify if a Transaction the entire
group planned has been executed by a subset of the group or not. Once a plan
is created, it can have an Eventuality made. The Eventuality's extra is able
to be inserted into a HashMap, so all new on-chain transactions can be
trivially checked as potential candidates. Once a potential candidate is found,
a check involving ECC ops can be performed.
While this is arguably a DoS vector, the underlying Monero blockchain would
need to be spammed with transactions to trigger it. Accordingly, it becomes
a Monero blockchain DoS vector, when this code is written on the premise
of the Monero blockchain functioning. Accordingly, it is considered handled.
If a forgery does match, it must have created the exact same outputs the
multisig would've. Accordingly, it's argued the multisig shouldn't mind.
This entire suite of code is only necessary due to the lack of outgoing
view keys, yet it's able to avoid an interactive protocol to communicate
key images on every single received output.
While this could be locked to the multisig feature, there's no practical
benefit to doing so.
* Add support for encoding Monero address to instructions
* Move Serai's Monero address encoding into serai-client
serai-client is meant to be a single library enabling using Serai. While it was
originally written as an RPC client for Serai, apps actually using Serai will
primarily be sending transactions on connected networks. Sending those
transactions require proper {In, Out}Instructions, including proper address
encoding.
Not only has address encoding been moved, yet the subxt client is now behind
a feature. coin integrations have their own features, which are on by default.
primitives are always exposed.
* Reorganize file layout a bit, add feature flags to processor
* Tidy up ETH Dockerfile
* Add Bitcoin address encoding
* Move Bitcoin::Address to serai-client's
* Comment where tweaking needs to happen
* Add an API to check if a plan was completed in a specific TX
This allows any participating signer to submit the TX ID to prevent further
signing attempts.
Also performs some API cleanup.
* Minimize FROST dependencies
* Use a seeded RNG for key gen
* Tweak keys from Key gen
* Test proper usage of Branch/Change addresses
Adds a more descriptive error to an error case in decoys, and pads Monero
payments as needed.
* Also test spending the change output
* Add queued_plans to the Scheduler
queued_plans is for payments to be issued when an amount appears, yet the
amount is currently pre-fee. One the output is actually created, the
Scheduler should be notified of the amount it was created with, moving from
queued_plans to plans under the actual amount.
Also tightens debug_asserts to asserts for invariants which may are at risk of
being exclusive to prod.
* Add missing tweak_keys call
* Correct decoy selection height handling
* Add a few log statements to the scheduler
* Simplify test's get_block_number
* Simplify, while making more robust, branch address handling in Scheduler
* Have fees deducted from payments
Corrects Monero's handling of fees when there's no change address.
Adds a DUST variable, as needed due to 1_00_000_000 not being enough to pay
its fee on Monero.
* Add comment to Monero
* Consolidate BTC/XMR prepare_send code
These aren't fully consolidated. We'd need a SignableTransaction trait for
that. This is a lot cleaner though.
* Ban integrated addresses
The reasoning why is accordingly documented.
* Tidy TODOs/dust handling
* Update README TODO
* Use a determinisitic protocol version in Monero
* Test rebuilt KeyGen machines function as expected
* Use a more robust KeyGen entropy system
* Add DB TXNs
Also load entropy from env
* Add a loop for processing messages from substrate
Allows detecting if we're behind, and if so, waiting to handle the message
* Set Monero MAX_INPUTS properly
The previous number was based on an old hard fork. With the ring size having
increased, transactions have since got larger.
* Distinguish TODOs into TODO and TODO2s
TODO2s are for after protonet
* Zeroize secret share repr in ThresholdCore write
* Work on Eventualities
Adds serialization and stops signing when an eventuality is proven.
* Use a more robust DB key schema
* Update to {k, p}256 0.12
* cargo +nightly clippy
* cargo update
* Slight message-box tweaks
* Update to recent Monero merge
* Add a Coordinator trait for communication with coordinator
* Remove KeyGenHandle for just KeyGen
While KeyGen previously accepted instructions over a channel, this breaks the
ack flow needed for coordinator communication. Now, KeyGen is the direct object
with a handle() function for messages.
Thankfully, this ended up being rather trivial for KeyGen as it has no
background tasks.
* Add a handle function to Signer
Enables determining when it's finished handling a CoordinatorMessage and
therefore creating an acknowledgement.
* Save transactions used to complete eventualities
* Use a more intelligent sleep in the signer
* Emit SignedTransaction with the first ID *we can still get from our node*
* Move Substrate message handling into the new coordinator recv loop
* Add handle function to Scanner
* Remove the plans timer
Enables ensuring the ordring on the handling of plans.
* Remove the outputs function which panicked if a precondition wasn't met
The new API only returns outputs upon satisfaction of the precondition.
* Convert SignerOrder::SignTransaction to a function
* Remove the key_gen object from sign_plans
* Refactor out get_fee/prepare_send into dedicated functions
* Save plans being signed to the DB
* Reload transactions being signed on boot
* Stop reloading TXs being signed (and report it to peers)
* Remove message-box from the processor branch
We don't use it here yet.
* cargo +nightly fmt
* Move back common/zalloc
* Update subxt to 0.27
* Zeroize ^1.5, not 1
* Update GitHub workflow
* Remove usage of SignId in completed
* Use Monero-compatible additional TX keys
This still sends a fingerprinting flare up if you send to a subaddress which
needs to be fixed. Despite that, Monero no should no longer fail to scan TXs
from monero-serai regarding additional keys.
Previously it failed becuase we supplied one key as THE key, and n-1 as
additional. Monero expects n for additional.
This does correctly select when to use THE key versus when to use the additional
key when sending. That removes the ability for recipients to fingerprint
monero-serai by receiving to a standard address yet needing to use an additional
key.
* Add tokens_primitives
Moves OutInstruction from in-instructions.
Turns Destination into OutInstruction.
* Correct in-instructions DispatchClass
* Add initial tokens pallet
* Don't allow pallet addresses to equal identity
* Add support for InInstruction::transfer
Requires a cargo update due to modifications made to serai-dex/substrate.
Successfully mints a token to a SeraiAddress.
* Bind InInstructions to an amount
* Add a call filter to the runtime
Prevents worrying about calls to the assets pallet/generally tightens things
up.
* Restore Destination
It was meged into OutInstruction, yet it didn't make sense for OutInstruction
to contain a SeraiAddress.
Also deletes the excessively dated Scenarios doc.
* Split PublicKey/SeraiAddress
Lets us define a custom Display/ToString for SeraiAddress.
Also resolves an oddity where PublicKey would be encoded as String, not
[u8; 32].
* Test burning tokens/retrieving OutInstructions
Modularizes processor_coinUpdates into a shared testing utility.
* Misc lint
* Don't use PolkadotExtrinsicParams
* Initial work on an In Inherents pallet
* Add an event for when a batch is executed
* Add a dummy provider for InInstructions
* Add in-instructions to the node
* Add the Serai runtime API to the processor
* Move processor tests around
* Build a subxt Client around Serai
* Successfully get Batch events from Serai
Renamed processor/substrate to processor/serai.
* Much more robust InInstruction pallet
* Implement the workaround from https://github.com/paritytech/subxt/issues/602
* Initial prototype of processor generated InInstructions
* Correct PendingCoins data flow for InInstructions
* Minor lint to in-instructions
* Remove the global Serai connection for a partial re-impl
* Correct ID handling of the processor test
* Workaround the delay in the subscription
* Make an unwrap an if let Some, remove old comments
* Lint the processor toml
* Rebase and update
* Move substrate/in-instructions to substrate/in-instructions/pallet
* Start an in-instructions primitives lib
* Properly update processor to subxt 0.24
Also corrects failures from the rebase.
* in-instructions cargo update
* Implement IsFatalError
* is_inherent -> true
* Rename in-instructions crates and misc cleanup
* Update documentation
* cargo update
* Misc update fixes
* Replace height with block_number
* Update processor src to latest subxt
* Correct pipeline for InInstructions testing
* Remove runtime::AccountId for serai_primitives::NativeAddress
* Rewrite the in-instructions pallet
Complete with respect to the currently written docs.
Drops the custom serializer for just using SCALE.
Makes slight tweaks as relevant.
* Move instructions' InherentDataProvider to a client crate
* Correct doc gen
* Add serde to in-instructions-primitives
* Add in-instructions-primitives to pallet
* Heights -> BlockNumbers
* Get batch pub test loop working
* Update in instructions pallet terminology
Removes the ambiguous Coin for Update.
Removes pending/artificial latency for furture client work.
Also moves to using serai_primitives::Coin.
* Add a BlockNumber primitive
* Belated cargo fmt
* Further document why DifferentBatch isn't fatal
* Correct processor sleeps
* Remove metadata at compile time, add test framework for Serai nodes
* Remove manual RPC client
* Simplify update test
* Improve re-exporting behavior of serai-runtime
It now re-exports all pallets underneath it.
* Add a function to get storage values to the Serai RPC
* Update substrate/ to latest substrate
* Create a dedicated crate for the Serai RPC
* Remove unused dependencies in substrate/
* Remove unused dependencies in coins/
Out of scope for this branch, just minor and path of least resistance.
* Use substrate/serai/client for the Serai RPC lib
It's a bit out of place, since these client folders are intended for the node to
access pallets and so on. This is for end-users to access Serai as a whole.
In that sense, it made more sense as a top level folder, yet that also felt
out of place.
* Move InInstructions test to serai-client for now
* Final cleanup
* Update deny.toml
* Cargo.lock update from merging develop
* Update nightly
Attempt to work around the current CI failure, which is a Rust ICE.
We previously didn't upgrade due to clippy 10134, yet that's been reverted.
* clippy
* clippy
* fmt
* NativeAddress -> SeraiAddress
* Sec fix on non-provided updates and doc fixes
* Add Serai as a Coin
Necessary in order to swap to Serai.
* Add a BlockHash type, used for batch IDs
* Remove origin from InInstruction
Makes InInstructionTarget. Adds RefundableInInstruction with origin.
* Document storage items in in-instructions
* Rename serai/client/tests/serai.rs to updates.rs
It only tested publishing updates and their successful acceptance.
